American Family Insurance Pay My Bill – All Payment Methods

American Family Insurance provides several ways to manage your premium and pay your bill online. You can make a one-time payment using some basic policy information without creating an account or logging in. Managing your account, storing payment information, and making recurring payments is done by creating an account. Whichever option you choose you will be able to pay your bill by following the steps outlined below with the American Family Insurance website.

American Family Insurance Pay My Bill Online

First you will need to decide which bill payment option works for you, whether you want to make a one-time payment without creating an account, or by creating an account and storing your information for future use.

To pay your bill without logging in:

  • Start at the American Family Insurance website
  • In the box to the right under the login information, click on the ‘Make a Payment’ option which will open a drop down with two choices, pay now or learn more – choose ‘Pay Now’ Pay

  • By clicking pay now you will be brought to the one-time payment page where you will enter your billing number, which is located on your statement, and zip code
  • On the next screen, you will enter your payment details – credit or debit card or bank information – and then click to review and then confirm the payment
  • You should get a confirmation that your payment is complete, and your payment will have been successfully made.

To create an account and log in to pay your bill:

  • Again, you’ll start on the AmFam main home page of the website
  • If you’ve created an account in the past, you’ll just need to enter your user ID and password in the box to the right to sign in. Create Account

  • If it’s your first-time logging in, under the sign in box look to the bottom right and click on the highlighted link for ‘Create Account’ and choose business or personal account as shown on the screen. Enroll

  • You’ll need to enter your Last name, birth date, and zip code to first locate your policy, then you will confirm it’s the correct account, create a user ID, and choose your security questions Enrollment

  • Follow the instructions on the next page to complete your payment.

Other Ways to Pay Your AmFam Bill

If you’d prefer to pay your American Family Insurance premium in a different way other than online, you have a few options.

  • To pay by phone: You can call 800-MYAMFAM and follow the prompts of the automated phone system
  • To pay by mail: Use the convenient payment stub and envelope that came with your statement, and enclose a check or money order or mail to:
    American Family Insurance Companies
    6000 American Parkway
    Madison, WI 53783
We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply